I posted about our Christmas Eve Feast of Seven Fishes and I thought I would go into more detail about the many dishes and how I prepared them. I’m doing this for you the reader, but since the Feast only comes once a year, I thought I should blog the details so I can remember next year.
That said, Carrie and I agreed that we won’t try 13 12 dishes ever again. It was way too complicated, way too much food – though the leftovers were off the hook – and we feel if we focus on seven, each will come out better and there won’t be as much stress. Even though all of the food prepared for the Feast came out beautifully, I have to admit that I stressed out a bit just before and during the actual cook.
What follows is a numbered version of the plated feast and a description of each item.

Our Christmas Eve Feast of Seven Fishes for two. Click for a slightly larger version.
#1 & #10 Sous Vide Lobster and Shrimp:
The Lobster Tail weighed in at almost a pound (with the shell). I’ve never attempted this large of a tail AND I’ve never attempted anything Sous Vide, but what better time than the Feast of Seven Fishes? This was so simple that I will do this again, even for large groups if the need arises. Simply put, I thawed and shelled the tail completely, placed the rinsed and dried tail in a vacuum seal bag with a lot of fresh unsalted butter. I tossed 4 shrimp in the bag as well.
Sealer Failure
I stuck the open end of the lobster filled bag into the brand new FoodSaver and as the air was removed, I could see moisture headed for the seal, I stopped it and it tried to seal but there were places that allowed air in. I made a longer bag and dried the inside as best I could before my second attempt. It worked better, but those things have a lot of moisture in them and I saw some questionable spots in the seal, so I just inserted the same sealed bag into the sealer and let it seal again – it worked!
I filled an electric roaster pan almost full of water – the more the better – and took it up to 145° and then turned it off. I placed my well sealed bag of lobster into the water, set the timer for 25 minutes and watched the temperature slowly drop to 140°. I turned the roaster back on for a few minutes and then I dropped my digital (electric) thermometer in the water at about the 20 minute mark. DOH! Oh well, it was holding at a steady 140° so I turned it off and started getting ready for the other food.
When the timer went off, I removed the bag from the water and placed it on the counter while I finished up on the other dishes.
The result was the most amazing lobster tail – and shrimp – I’ve ever tasted. It super tender and filled with buttery flavor. There was some connective tissue on the bottom that I have to learn how to trim, but other than that, this was an award winner.
#2 Pan Seared Tuna Steak
The Tuna was a large hunk purchased at the fish counter at Kroger. It was super fresh and while I don’t know what kind it was, this was one super fine looking piece of fish. I used a cast iron pan and seared it in very hot clarified butter for about 2 minutes on each side. I wish I would have cut it open for the picture because it looks brown and over cooked – it was not! The juicy red center was very tender and tasty. I will add more seasoning – of which I added none – next time because it needed a flavor kick. Other than that, it came out great.
#3 Pan Seared Sea Scallops
The Sea Scallops came from Sam’s Club. I have a regular technique that I use with these. After I thaw them, I put them on a rack on the counter and let them dry out a little. Then I put them in smoking hot clarified butter for about a minute on each side. I wait to turn them until little fingers of charing start coming up the sides. It works out perfect every time.
#4 Deep Fried Atlantic Cod in Panco Breadcrumbs
These came frozen from Walmart. It said on the label that they were wild caught Atlantic cod. I’ve been wanting to try this fish for a while and there was no better time than the present. The technique was discovered by accident. As I’ll explain in the oysters (#5), I followed the same technique, though I didn’t let them dry on the counter, they did get breaded an hour before the oil bath and they came out beautifully. About 2.5 minutes on each side and they were brown on the outside and tender on the inside. We liked this so much in fact that I made some more last night. The fish is great, the technique is flawless. Read below – and I’ll be making another post about the deep fry method shortly.
#5 Panco Breaded, Deep Fried Oysters
I was a little concerned about these because I have never made them before. I’ve never been a big fan of oysters but Carrie requested this as part of our Feast. After power Googling for a few minutes, I discovered that people ‘complain’ about the breading falling off while being cooked. I read three or four techniques that claimed to prevent it. I wish I could remember where I read it, but it seems that it’s important to thoroughly rinse, dry and bread early. Using what I gleaned from numerous websites, I came up with my own plan.
- Rinse and dry each oyster
- Place each on a paper towel and cover with another – make sure they are not touching each other
- Allow to sit on the counter for 30 minutes – drying
- Bread each oyster and place on a cookie sheet
- Place cookie sheet in the refrigerator for at least 60 minutes
- Remove and fry
I am assuming that drying the oyster before and after they are breaded help the breading “grip” the flesh. I used the same technique on the fried cod and shrimp, though I did not let those sit on the counter before breading.
About the Panco breading. I more or less used the instructions on the box. It was easy.
- Place about 2 cups of flour in a bowl
- Add any seasoning you wish, I added black pepper and cayenne. Note: I did NOT add any salt because oysters are known to be salty enough on their own.
- Crack two eggs into a bowl with 2 tbsp of both water and milk and beat like crazy
- In a third bowl, pour Panco breadcrumbs
- Coat each oyster with the flour, shake excess
- Dip into the egg mixture covering completely
- Place into the Panco and bury it. Press lightly on the Panco to push the breadcrumbs into the flesh
- Remove from Panco, shake lightly to remove very loose breadcrumbs and place on cookie sheet
- Repeat for each leaving space between each oyster so they are not touching and can dry
Now for the frying – it is very important that your oil of choice is HOT! I used an oil thermometer to make sure the oil was exactly 350°, then I turned off the burner, added the oysters, replaced the thermometer and turned the burner back on. I cooked the oysters for about 2 minutes on each side, testing the tenderness throughout the process and monitoring the oil temperature closely. Once they were golden brown and firm to the touch, I removed them and let them drain on a paper towel. I cooked the shrimp at the same time and the cod fish after.
These well breaded oysters came out perfect. Carrie said they were better than at any restaurant she’s been to. Since I don’t usually eat oysters, I’ll differ to her expertise. That said, I ate the oysters too and they were outstanding. I had no trouble with the breading falling off of the oyster, nor the shrimp or fish. This breading technique is a keeper for sure.
#6 Asian Zing Shrimp
This was not in the photo – We buy our frozen shrimp at Wal-Mart, they are the Wal-Mart brand. We like the “Colossal” which are headless, shelled, de-vained, with the tail still on. We’ve tried many brands from many stores, we feel these are the best in our area and even go out of our way to buy them. Sure, the fresh shrimp we get on St. George Island are much better, but in land locked Bowling Green, these are about the best we can get.
Preparation is simple, get a wok, dump about half a bottle of McCormick Asian Zing into the pan. On medium heat, warm the sauce, add the thawed shrimp and cook until done. I’ve done this so many times I have no idea how long it takes, about 3 – 5 minutes. It’s got the right amount of salt, peppers and, well, zing that makes for a very tasty shrimp dish.
#7 Blackened Atlantic Cod
The photo doesn’t do this dish justice. I simply sprinkled blackening seasoning onto the thawed fish and pan seared it in a small amount of clarified butter until done. About 2 minutes per side or so. The seasoning came from our good friends who come from New Orleans. On a recent visit, they picked us up some and it was great. Since it was my first time with it, I didn’t realize how salty it was, will use less next time.
#8 Broiled Tilapia With Old Bay Seasoning
This dish didn’t turn out very well. Actually, this is one of our favorites and we have it several times a year, but we were out of Old Bay. Carrie decided to use some “Canjun Seasoning” instead and it wasn’t what we wanted. The fish was cooked perfectly, but the seasoning overpowered the fish. So overpowering in fact that we threw away the bottle the next day.
#9 Panco Breaded Deep Fried Shrimp
We use the same shrimp as in number six for this too. Carrie picked this as her favorite of the 12 dishes, and she doesn’t even prefer shrimp. I admit, I kind of knocked the ball out of the park with this one – though my favorite was the lobster – and I think the breading technique (as with the oysters in #5) was the key. Crunchy, juicy goodness! I used exactly the same technique as with the oysters including the breading and frying. Can’t miss.
#10 Sous Vide Shrimp
As I mentioned in #1, I just threw these in with the lobster. You could taste the butter and even cooking for 25 minutes, these babies had a great texture – snap – to them. I can see myself doing pounds of shrimp this way.
#11 Muscles in Garlic Sauce
This was a late addition to the Feast. When we couldn’t find any halibut, grouper or swordfish, even from our local (only) butcher shop, I found myself scanning the frozen seafood collections at a variety of grocery stores. I can’t remember the brand, but we got them at Kroger in a black box. These were very simple since the garlic butter sauce was packed with the muscles. All I had to do was cut the bag open, and place the still frozen solid muscles into a saucepan and cover. 5 minutes later, they opened up and tasted great. I mean really great! As with oysters, I’m not a big fan, but I ate more of these than Carrie did. Hopefully, I’ll remember to buy these again and post the brand because these are brain dead simple and very tasty.
#12 Carrie’s Crab, Feta and Tortellini Salad
I hope to do a blog post just about this because we love it. Basically, it’s just well cooked tortellini – like right before they fall apart cooked – with Mayo, Feta and Imitation Crab. Now, before you get all cranky because it’s imitation, it is made from fish so it still qualifies for the feast. When I post the recipe, I’ll link back here.
Those were the seafood dishes, now on to the sides.
#13 Pan Seared Bussels Sprouts with Sriracha Sauce and Agave Nectar
This was something Carrie had seen on TV and wanted to try it. It’s very simple really. We took some fresh Brussels Sprouts, cut them in half and trimmed the stems and tossed them into a little hot oil. The outsides where charring very well but the insides were not cooking fast enough so I added about a cup of water and covered until the water was gone. It helped with the tenderness and helped cook out the bitterness… mostly.
The sriracha sauce and agave nectar was amazing! Equal amounts of both added some sweet heat to the sprouts. They say that Béchamel Sauce is one of the mother sauces, but sriracha sauce is the grandmother, queen, goddess of sauces to us. It’s got a good bite. It can be found in the Asian section of most well stocked grocery stores.
#14 Clarified Butter
I learned how to do this a few months ago and it’s great! You can use it for frying, seasoning and in this case dipping. There are a jillian methods and hundreds of videos online about how to do this. My method is simple. Place a block (1lb) of unsalted butter in a saucepan and set to low. Wait about 45 minutes, skim off the top and pour into a container. Be careful not to let any of the white stuff (milk fat) on the bottom pour out. I haven’t found a use for the milk fat but I’ve read it’s good on popcorn.
#15 Apple, Banana and Avocado Chutney with Agave Nectar and small batch with Agavero Tequila.
I’ve written about this before. It pairs nicely with seafood and meat. Just dice up the apple, banana and avacado, douse with a little key lime and coat with agave nectar. You can add a little hot pepper if you like, I added “Agavero” Tequila to mine and the spices came through beautifully.
#16 Carrie’s Tartar Sauce
While I was doing other things, Carrie whipped up this tarter sauce that was great. I’m not sure what was in it, but will post if she ever shares her secret recipe with me.
#17 Cocktail Sauce
As with the tartar sauce, Carrie whipped this up behind my back. Basically ketchup and horseradish, she added a few other ingredients and it was good. A little light on the horsey sauce but still really great.
#18 Crème Fraîche with Fresh Italian Parsley and Garlic Powder
Crème Fraîche is a fairly new discovery to me. I learned how to make it from scratch – 1 cup heavy cream and 2 tbs of buttermilk – and I have been looking for excuses to make it ever since. It’s like a creamy-light sour cream. I made it for my poached pears in November for the first time, but saw it used with lobster and decided to give it a try. I added the parsley and garlic to go with the seafood and it was amazing. I’ll be posting about Crème Fraîche soon.
And there you have it – maybe too much of it. Like I said, this is for my benefit as well as yours. If you’re still reading, let me tell you it took longer to write this out than it took to prepare the majority of these dishes. The idea of such a large endeavor seems impossible, but the hard work was well worth it. We saved the leftovers and they warmed up great. It wasn’t as hard as it looks and now we have a new Christmas Eve tradition of our own.
I do have to give JohnGL of the Alcoholian blog most of the credit for this meal. Everything from the sous vide, to how to pan sear fish to the chutney, I’ve learned a lot from him this year and those lessons made this feast a success… THANKS JOHN!
As always, thanks for reading.